NOTICE:
This content is in the "archives" of Gadgetopia. It has been moved to this subdomain as it is no longer considered relevant to the site. It is being hosted here for a indeterminate period of time. Its existence at this URL is not guaranteed, and it may be removed at any time. If you would like to refer to this content in the future, you are encouraged to save it to your local file system.

How WordPress Beat the Pants off Movable Type

Originally published by "dbarker" on 2011-02-10 14:43:00Z

How did WordPress win?: Here’s a blog post written by a former Six Apart engineer about how Movable Type lost to WordPress in the battle of the blogging platforms.

It’s long, but informative.  He starts off with these three reasons – which are, lets face it, the most obvious – but then moves on to say much more about what happened.

Movable Type’s licensing fiasco in 2004 angered the community and drove users to WordPress […] Movable Type is not open source. WordPress is.  […] Movable Type is written in Perl, while WordPress is written in PHP.

Gadgetopia still runs on Movable Type, believe it or not.  There’s just not a compelling reason to change right now – MT does the job I’ve asked it to.  (Thought, to be honest, all MT is doing is generating files that define PHP object instances – all the templating is done in PHP.)

Adam Kalsey pointed me to Melody the other day.  For all my experience with MT, I didn’t even know this existed.

What I find interesting is that MT/Melody is still a decoupled CMS platform – probably the cheapest, most current one you’ll find.  Most all CMS these days are coupled, but MT/Melody is still doing flat file generation, which is really handy in a lot of cases.  There are still many, many environments where this is the only option that will work.

Comment by "Thud" on 2011-02-10 14:56:00Z
I remember the licensing fiasco! I had been a MT blogger for two years at the time, and I dropped MT for Textpattern and, later, Wordpress because of it.
Comment by "Deane" on 2011-02-10 14:58:00Z
The licensing thing didn't bother me that much, I guess. I always knew they were going to start changing at some point. I paid it.
Comment by "Adam" on 2011-02-10 17:56:00Z
Yeah, I paid, too, and then gave credit to Six Apart for changing their terms when it became clear that they'd made a mistake. It seems too many people wouldn't forgive...
Comment by "Byrne Reese" on 2011-02-17 08:10:00Z
It was always amazing to me how, even after all these years, the licensing fiasco is still very close to the surface for a lot of people. Even mentioning Movable Type is like talking about someone's ex-girlfriend who cheated on them. Yeah, time heals all wounds, but still what a f***ing b****h. High five.