NOTICE:
This content is in the "archives" of a retired blog called Gadgetopia. It has been moved to this subdomain as it is no longer considered relevant to the site. It is being hosted here for a indeterminate period of time. Its existence at this URL is not guaranteed, and it may be removed at any time. If you would like to refer to this content in the future, you are encouraged to save it to your local file system.

Some content from Gadgetopia was moved to the technical blog on deanebarker.net

The “Standard Reference” Theory: Two Years On

Originally published by "dbarker" on 2007-08-13 17:59:00Z

It’s been another year, so it’s time to re-evaluate my theory that Wikipedia is becoming a standard reference and will soon be the number one hit for notable people in the world. Consider my two previous discussions here:

Again, I will Google for all the people in my list, and show how their results compare to last year and the year before that.

Those results are compelling: the average placement of the Wikipedia page is:

Clearly, the Wikipedia page for a notable person is fast being considered the single most important representation of them on the Web.

Two years back, I also checked four media personalities – Cary Grant, Brad Pitt, George Lucas, and Client Howard – to see where the IMDb ranked in their results. This year, their IMDb page was first for all of them. So, the average looks like this:

Last year I introduced books to the mix, in an attempt to prove that a book’s Amazon listing is equivalent to a person’s Wikipedia page. Here are this year’s results, compared to last year’s:

These results are much more mixed. Average placement of the Amazon page:

The Amazon page ranking actually got worse.

Until next year…

Comment by "Dave" on 2007-08-13 15:31:00Z
>Clearly, the Wikipedia page for a notable person is fast being considered the single most important representation of them on the Web. That's assuming Google Pagerank to be a good determinant of that. Isn't there some tight relationship between Google and Wikipedia that gives precedence to info in Wikipedia in a Google search? I recall reading of some controversy about that recently.